The List, Episode 7: Former baseball coach Randy Mettemeyer breaks down favorite fictional baseball players

Play Video

QUINCY — From playing baseball at Monmouth College to coaching at Quincy High School and with the Quincy Gems during the Central Illinois Collegiate League days, Randy Mettemeyer has spent enough time on the road to have watched a baseball movie or two.

That made him the perfect person to join Muddy River Sports Editor Matt Schuckman to break down their lists of their favorite fictional baseball players of all-time. Take a listen and find out who makes their lists.

If you want to chime in with your favorite fictional baseball players, email Schuckman at, find him on X at @SchuckSports, comment on Facebook or track him down at a game.

Miss Clipping Out Stories to Save for Later?

Click the Purchase Story button below to order a print of this story. We will print it for you on matte photo paper to keep forever.

Related Articles